01 /Key findings
- Ashwagandha, 15 studies, 873 adults: a pooled analysis of randomized trials in adults with stress and/or anxiety (BJPsych Open, 2025). Outcomes: cortisol, the Perceived Stress Scale (PSS) and the Hamilton Anxiety Scale (HAM-A).
- Rhodiola SHR-5, 60 adults, 576 mg a day for 28 days: a double-blind trial against placebo in adults with stress-related fatigue (Planta Medica, 2009). Outcomes: a burnout scale, attention tests and the cortisol response on waking.
- Rhodiola extract, 80 adults with mild anxiety, 14 days: compared with a group that received nothing, not with placebo (Phytotherapy Research, 2015). Outcomes: self-reported anxiety, stress, anger, confusion and depression; cognition.
02 /The myth: “One of the two is the proven stress supplement”
Short answer: no study in these sources compares them. The ashwagandha analysis pooled 15 studies and 873 adults and measured cortisol and two questionnaires. Rhodiola was tested in 60 adults with stress-related fatigue for 28 days, and in 80 adults with mild anxiety for 14 days, without a placebo. Different people, different measures.
03 /What did the ashwagandha analysis measure?
The authors looked for trials of ashwagandha in adults with stress and/or anxiety. They pooled 15, with 873 people in all. It names three outcomes. Cortisol is a lab test. The PSS is a questionnaire on perceived stress. The HAM-A is a questionnaire on anxiety symptoms.
The abstract reports significant differences from placebo in all three. For the PSS and the HAM-A it reports the 8-week result. This page does not copy the size of those differences. It gives no dose or extract, because the abstract gives none.
04 /What did the rhodiola trials measure?
The 2009 trial put 60 adults with stress-related fatigue on the SHR-5 extract, 576 mg a day, or on placebo, for 28 days. The abstract describes differences in a burnout scale, in attention and in the cortisol response on waking. That last one needs saliva samples taken after waking.
The 2015 trial is different. It put 80 adults with mild anxiety on a rhodiola extract or in a control group that got nothing, for 14 days. Every outcome was self-reported. Its authors state that they could not establish causation.
05 /Can you compare the three?
Only side by side, and the columns do not line up.
Status Estimated
| Source | People | Design | Length | Outcomes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ashwagandha, pooled analysis | 873 adults with stress and/or anxiety | 15 trials combined | PSS and HAM-A at 8 weeks | Cortisol, PSS, HAM-A |
| Rhodiola SHR-5, 2009 | 60 adults, stress-related fatigue | Double-blind, placebo | 28 days | Burnout scale, attention, cortisol on waking |
| Rhodiola extract, 2015 | 80 adults, mild anxiety | Randomized, no placebo | 14 days | Self-reported anxiety, stress, anger, confusion, depression; cognition |
For “ashwagandha vs rhodiola for stress,” these sources give no ranking. The groups differ. The measures differ. Only one rhodiola trial used a placebo.
06 /Could a ring or band see any of these outcomes?
None of them. Cortisol comes from a lab sample. The PSS, the HAM-A and the burnout scale are questionnaires. The attention tests are performance tasks, and the 2015 outcomes are self-reports. None of these studies used a wearable signal as an outcome.
07 /Where the evidence ends
- The ashwagandha source is a conference abstract in a journal supplement, not a full article.
- It pools adults with stress and/or anxiety, so it is not a result for a person with no complaint.
- The 2009 rhodiola trial is a single trial of 60 adults over 28 days.
- The 2015 rhodiola trial had no placebo.
- Other ashwagandha and rhodiola trials exist. This page does not use them.
- None of this says what either extract would do for you.
Mental Work — all protocols
08 /What it means
To read a stress study, check three things. Who was enrolled? What was measured? What did the comparison group get? On all three, these sources differ. This page does not rank them.
More on ashwagandha: Ashwagandha evidence and Can a ring verify ashwagandha?. On anxiety: Natural anxiety remedies.
Quick questions
What did the ashwagandha analysis measure?
The authors looked for trials of ashwagandha in adults with stress and/or anxiety. They pooled 15, with 873 people in all. It names three outcomes. Cortisol is a lab test. The PSS is a questionnaire on perceived stress. The HAM-A is a questionnaire on anxiety symptoms.
What did the rhodiola trials measure?
The 2009 trial put 60 adults with stress-related fatigue on the SHR-5 extract, 576 mg a day, or on placebo, for 28 days. The abstract describes differences in a burnout scale, in attention and in the cortisol response on waking. That last one needs saliva samples taken after waking. The 2015 trial is different.
Can you compare the three?
Only side by side, and the columns do not line up. For “ashwagandha vs rhodiola for stress,” these sources give no ranking. The groups differ. The measures differ. Only one rhodiola trial used a placebo.
Could a ring or band see any of these outcomes?
None of them. Cortisol comes from a lab sample. The PSS, the HAM-A and the burnout scale are questionnaires. The attention tests are performance tasks, and the 2015 outcomes are self-reports. None of these studies used a wearable signal as an outcome.
Sources
- Bachour et al., Effects of Ashwagandha Supplements on Cortisol, Stress, and Anxiety Levels in Adults, BJPsych Open 2025 · PMC12242034
- Olsson et al., SHR-5 of Rhodiola rosea in stress-related fatigue, Planta Medica 2009 · PMID 19016404
- The Effects of Rhodiola rosea L. Extract on Anxiety, Stress, Cognition and Other Mood Symptoms, Phytotherapy Research 2015 · PMID 26502953
Alejandro del PalacioAuthor · reviewed 2026-11-17
A measurement tool, not medical advice.
pieza_id p1-ashwagandha-vs-rhodiola-stress
